December 15, 2010 The Question today is, Brushstrokes Showing or not?

This is a commission painting I finished a few weeks ago. "Summertime at Lake Alamoostook" 11x14 Oil on Copper panel has no visible brushstrokes showing. The man wanted me to paint his photo. I thought about whether I should depict a painting as close to his photo as possible or should I create a painting in my normal style with brushstrokes? I decided to render a painting with no brushstrokes to resemble his photograph as closely as possible. I think it was a good decision. I know he will be pleased. This is the view from his Summer cottage on this lake. I imagine when he is hard at work, this painting will give him a sense of peace.
This Summer I decided to have my brushstrokes showing. Before the Summer, I was undecided and I really hadn't thought about it. Some of my paintings showed brushstrokes and some painting didn't. Yesterday I was reading Jan Herring's book, "The Painter's Composition Handbook". I have been drinking lots of Blue Mountain Jamacian Coffee here in Florida which seems to be getting me thinking more than normal! I read this, "This gesture drawing was executed in a matter of seconds with the use of continuous line (this is when a pencil never comes up off of the page but continues). The aim was to capture an attitude of the model rather than a exact likeness. Such technique can often be more appealing than a factual drawing created through laborious effect. The emotional impact is strong because of the fluid flow of line."
I was thinking about my pen and ink with watercolors of the snowman. I was comparing this paragraph of Jan Herring's book with my recent drawings. I do think these imperfect sketches of snowman are somewhat emotional. I wasn't going to post them as I knew they were roughly done. So many people who read the blog commented how much they loved them. Fast drawings can be more effective than hours of finished drawings. I think that is why I prefer to work plein aire. The painting is fast! There is more emotion. It is difficult to have brushstrokes concealed. There is emotional impact in these plein aire paintings.
Next I was reading "Problem Solving for Oil Painters" by Gregg Kreutz again. I liked what he said about painting light. Here are a few of his sentences I will share with you: "If a picture doesn't have light flowing throught it, it looks weak. You can use pure color, splatter on the paint, outline everything in purple-but if you neglect the vibrancy of insightfully dipicted light, the picture will only look superficially exciting. The artist has somehow to convert that light into strokes of paint. To get the look of the object, you must analyze the light on it. What direction is it coming from? What color is it? How bright is it? How much of the object's surface does it conver? All of these questions have to be asked and answered. Such a procedure is hard, more like science than many people expect art to be. We like the idea of the artist almost sword-fighting with the canvas, making dynamic strokes that explode out of an inner vision. All the great artists of the past must have put in their time staring at the apple. That's where a lot of power resides. They figured out what was going on, and their paintings pass that distillation and analysis on to the viewer. "
This is the part I really liked, "The exciting brushwork and dazzling paint manipulation that many of them used (I'm thinking of Frans Hals or John Singer Sargent) are based on keen observation. To get a bravura look, you really have to discover explicitly how the light reveals the form. That means concentration and analysis. The artist may be expressive, may even be sword-fighting slightly, but mainly he or she is figuring out how to turn the interaction of light and form into paint." I looked up the word bravura in the dictionary. It means: A bold attempt attempt or display of daring. Or a brilliant passage or piece that displays the preformer's skill.
To have your brushstrokes showing or not? This is the question all artists have encountered. Sometimes it happens naturally an artist chooses to show their brushstrokes. When brushstrokes are visible, there can be an emotional impact for the viewer to see. The raised paint textures allow the viewer to have something more to study. The art work with visible brushstrokes will be never mistaken for a print.
A work of art without brushstrokes can be visually peaceful. It is difficult to hide brushstrokes. I find I have to work slower. Glazing over and over using very little paint is a technique used to show no brushwork. Using a fan brush works to eliminate brushstrokes. There is no right or wrong concerning brushstrokes. It is only a conscious choice an artist must decide. 
Here is a photo of Fishbeach plein aire painters on Monhegan Island. I recognize Allison Hill on the left painting. In the center is Don Stone behind the man carrying something. They were all gathered together to paint in the morning. I love to paint here too.
Here is the Monhegan Island bell and their Museum. This bell is very interesting. Each of it's legs are turned a different direction. Not many painters paint this bell. It is very difficult to draw.
Have a great day! Boy that Blue Mountain coffee is good! I painted 4 paintings yesterday. When I get home I will show you them.
Comments
2 Responses to December 15, 2010 The Question today is, Brushstrokes Showing or not?
Leave a Comment